This is one of the first real forks in the road for any kitchen renovation, and it shapes almost every decision that follows. Here's how to think it through properly.
Space
An open kitchen, with minimal walls, tends to make a home feel larger and airier, which matters a lot in a smaller HDB flat. A closed kitchen trades that openness for more storage capacity, since it can use both upper and lower cabinetry, whereas an open layout is often limited to storage below the counter only.
How you actually cook
If your cooking involves strong smells, deep frying, or a lot of noise, a closed kitchen contains all of that within one room rather than letting it spread into soft furnishings throughout the home. An open kitchen risks that odour and noise travelling well beyond the kitchen itself.
Privacy versus connection
A closed kitchen gives you a private space to prep in peace. An open kitchen lets you keep talking with family or guests while you cook. Neither is objectively better — it comes down to which you'd rather have on a daily basis.
Safety, if you have young children
An open kitchen has more entry points, which makes childproofing harder. A closed kitchen is easier to keep off-limits, but it also makes it harder to keep an eye on kids in the next room while you're cooking.
Matching your home's overall design
The kitchen shouldn't feel disconnected from the rest of the home's layout. An open kitchen suits a home that's generally open-plan; a closed kitchen fits better where the rest of the home is already divided into distinct rooms.
Budget
Structural changes cost real money either way. Building new walls in a BTO costs more than simply keeping the existing open layout. Removing a wall in a resale flat generally starts from around $600, depending on the specifics. Glass partitions and a kitchen island are both worth considering as a cheaper middle ground.
There's no universal right answer
The choice comes down to your own priorities, not a fixed rule. A semi-open layout, using glass or foldable partitions, is a genuine hybrid option if you want some of the benefits of both.



